- David Archuleta - solid performance. Probably the best of the night.
- Kristy Lee Cook - getting better every week. If Kristy can keep it up, she could make the final 4. What a shock that would be! I won't mind seeing her some more til then...
- Brooke White - just an ok performance, not bad, not great, like Simon said, "Pleasant."
- Jason Castro - I thought he was ok, too, not the awesomeness that Randy saw. He bores me.
- Michael Johns - I liked it, but, dude, don't come out doing a rock song with that gay scarf on. Yechhhhh.
- David Cook - hard to put him in this list, but, I didn't know the song, and I couldn't understand the words. Was he sick? Is he getting too big for his head?
- Carly Smithson - I can finally say what I have been wanting to say about her the whole show - AWFUL! Truly awful.
- Syesha Mercado - Ok, if she doesn't stop with the Whitney, Celine, and now Fantasia songs, Simon is going to singlehandedly kick her off.